Henry Throop's Research Page

Research summary

Evolution of Orion circumstellar disks

I'm looking at planetesimal formation within the Orion nebula. In HST images, several dozen large `dark disks' are seen - dark only because they are blocking the light from the ionized gas of the Orion nebula region, silhouette-style. These disks may well be young solar systems in-formation -- like ours, but younger, perhaps 106 years years old. The disks are composed of gas & dust: the dust is what blocks the light, and the gas is what supplies most of their mass.

The Orion region itself is visible predominantly because of the Trapezium stars, OB stars which ionize the region nearby. Besides lighting up the whole area like a flashlight, UV photons from the Trapezium are tearing apart the disk like a cosmic leaf-blower attacking a pile of sand. Models of planet formation that ignore the effect of the OB stars may be skipping a good part of the physics! Plot of optical depth profiles vs. time, photoevaporated disk, Orion nebula

Evolutionary modeling

Planets form by collisional growth of small particles. But, particles can be blown away from the system by the hot wind blown off from the disks. If particles grow large enough, fast enough, they're safe, but small particles can be entrained and lost by the gas. We are modeling the growth of small particles is the photoevaporated disks.

We are also looking at planetesimal formation by gravitational instability -- a collective force that brings many small dust grains together. Although this method is not new, interest in it has been revitalized recently. Historically, gravitational instability is usually difficult because gas motions inhibit graisn from coming together. We are looking at methods where this can be mitigated -- for instance, if photo-evaporation removes the gas first, then gravitational instability can work subsequently.

Processes in the disk are turbulent. The main source of the turbulence is escaping heat which convects through the disk's atmosphere. The heat is generated both from the initial collapse of the disk, and from turbulent viscosity generated by shear within the disk.

Our model tracks the size distribution n(r,z,R,t) for particles in the disk. The particle growth process is a) collisional coagulation, and the loss processes are b) UV photosputtering, and c) removal of particles by entrainment in photoevaporating gas. We use a variable-timestep integrator to track the state vector for t ~ 106 years.

We find that, for typical input parameters, the optical depth of the disks is sharply terminated, at a distance R ~ 100 AU. Inward of this distance, particle growth is fast enough that particles are large enough (> 100 um) such that they are retained by the disk. Outward of this distance, particle growth is slower, particles remain small, and they are easily blown away by the escaping photoevaporative wind. Furthermore, grains can quickly settle to the midplane; if this happens and some gas is removed, then a gravitational instability in the remaining dust can occur.

Data vs. best-fit models for three Orion disks, HST WFPC2 Ha images

Observations

HST has been used to examine the disk images across the telescope's entire wavelength range, 0.25 .. 2.2 um. In each case, the light is generated behind the disk, photons pass through the disk, and we observe the silhouette of the disk against the bright emission nebula. The interaction between a photon and a particle is strongly dependent on their relative sizes; very small particles (r << lambda) cause blue skies & red sunsets. In the case of the proplyds, we found the disks to be not blue, not red, but completely grey across the wavelength range. This implies that the typical particle sizes are at least several times the wavelength, or > 5 um. Thus, rather than seeing individual 0.1 um grains, we're seeing aggregates, made of at least several thousand grains, which have grown in 105-6 years. This result is the first direct observation of growth within young circumstellar disks. Our evolutionary modeling is consistent with this result: in the sharply terminated edges, small particles are swept away, but large particles remain.

Implications

Papers and latest results!

2008Icarus: Accretion of Jupiter's Atmosphere from a Supernova-Contaminated Star Cluster, Throop & Bally (submitted)
2008AJ: Tail-End Bondi-Hoyle Accretion in Young Star Clusters: Implications for Disks, Planets, and Stars, Throop & Bally (PDF)
2008AJ: Dynamics and Light Scattering in Saturn's Rings, Porco et al
2008Space Science Reviews: Ralph: A Visible/Infrared Imager for the New Horizons Pluto/Kuiper Belt Mission, Reuter et al
2007GRL: New Horizons Alice UV Observations of a Stellar Occultation by Jupiter's Atmosphere, Greathouse et al
2007Science: Io’s Atmospheric Response to Eclipse: UV Aurorae Observations, Retherford et al (PDF)
2007Science: New Horizons Mapping of Europa and Ganymede, Grundy et al (PDF)
2007Science: Clump Detections and Limits on Moons in Jupiter’s Ring System, Showalter et al (PDF)
2007Science: Jupiter’s Nightside Airglow and Aurora, Gladstone et al (PDF)
2007Science: Polar Lightning and Decadal-Scale Cloud Variability on Jupiter, Baines et al (PDF)
2005ASP Conf Proc: Evolution of UV-Irradiated Protoplanetary Disks, Bally et al
2005ApJ: Phase Light Curves for Extrasolar Jupiters and Saturns, Dyudina et al
2004Cambridge Jupiter book: Jupiter's ring-moon system, Burns et al
2004Icarus: The Jovian rings: new results derived from Cassini, Galileo, Voyager, and Earth-based observations, Throop et al (PDF)
2004Icarus: The size distribution of Jupiter's main ring from Galileo imaging and spectroscopy, Brooks et al
2004ApJ: Can Photo-evaporation Trigger Planetesimal Formation?, Throop & Bally (astro-ph/0411647)
2003Science: Cassini Imaging of Jupiter's Atmosphere, Satellites, and Rings, Porco et al
2003ApJ: Evidence for Grain Growth in the Protostellar Disks of Orion, Shuping et al
2001Science: Large Dust Grains in Young Circumstellar Disks, Throop et al (PDF)
2000PhD thesis, Light Scattering and Evolution of Protoplanetary Disks and Planetary Rings (PDF, 2 MB)
1997Icarus: G ring particle sizes derived from ring plane crossing observations

Archived talks!

I haven't listed everything here, or put up PDFs for them all.  However, these are most of the interesting and orthogonal ones.

October 2008Poster at Spitzer 'New Light on Circumstellar Disks' conference: Accretion onto Young Disks (PDF, 3 MB)
October 2008DPS talk: Accretion of Jupiter's Atmosphere from a Supernova-contaminated Star Cluster (PDF, 3 MB)
October 2008ITT-VIS about the New Horizons Geometry Visualizer, winner of IDL 2008 'Application of the Year' (PDF, 4 MB)
August 2008Mexican Star Formation Workshop, Mexico City
June 2008National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM), Mexico City: Environmental Hazards of Star Formation (PDF, 3 MB)
May 2008Mexican Astrobiology Society conference, Mexico City
April 2008DDA meeting, Boulder, CO (PDF, 2 MB)
March 2008NASA-Goddard, Greenbelt, MD
October 2007DPS talk: Accretion Onto Young Circumstellar Disks
October 2007Oklahoma-Texas Star Party talk #2: Pluto and New Horizons (PDF, 66 MB!)
October 2007 Oklahoma-Texas Star Party talk #1: Star Formation (PDF, 8 MB)
September 2007University of Maryland, College Park
June 2007Poster at Extreme Solar Systems conference, Santorini, Greece (PDF, 3 MB)   [NB: An excellent example of how not to do a poster!]
September 2006Physics of Circumstellar Disks conference, Porto, Portugal: Dense Star Clusters: Hazard or Haven? (PDF, 4 MB)
May 2006Little Thompson Observatory: The Orion Nebula (PDF, 9 MB)
September 2005New Mexico State University, Las Cruces (PDF, 8 MB)
June 2005Observatoire de Nice, France
June 2005Physics of Dusty Rings workshop, Berne, Switzerland: Cassini Observations of the Jovian Ring (PDF, 2 MB)
December 2004AGU Poster: Formation of Organic Molecules in Photo-evaporating Pre-planetary Disks
November 2004DPS talk Can Photo-evaporation Trigger Planetesimal Formation? (PDF)
December 2001DPS talk Azimuthal Asymmetry in the A Ring (PDF)
December 2001

DPS talk Cassini Observations of Jupiter's Rings (PDF)

June 2001Boulder Jupiter meeting: Cassini observations of Jupiter's Rings (PDF)
April 2001Grinnell College: Dynamics of Planetary Rings
April 2001Grinnell College: The Frontiers of Star Formation
October 2000DPS talk (PDF)
October 2000Steward Observatory talk (PDF)
July 2000Ames talk (PDF)
May 2000PhD thesis talk (gzip'd postscript, 2.6 MB)
January 2000AAS talk: Large Grains in Young Circumstellar Disks (PDF)
October 1999DPS talk: Sandcastles in the Wind: Particle Growth in Externally Illuminated Young Circumstellar Disks (PS)
October 1996DPS talk: Particle Sizes in Saturn's G Ring


Book reviews

2003Astronomy: Solar System Voyage (Serge Brunier)
2003Astrobiology: Evolution of Planet Earth: The Impact of the Physical Environment (ed. Lister & Rothschild)
2003Astronomy: The Measure of All Things - The Seven-Year Odyssey and Hidden Error that Transformed the World (Ken Adler)
  NB: A great book about the French surveyors who defined and then measured the length of the meter, measuring by hand the size of the Earth

Future work

Other projects

Pluto!

HST/FOC image of Pluto and Charon

New Horizons Mission to Pluto

I am working with the instrument & science teams for Ralph, a visible-IR imaging spectrometer onboard the New Horizons mission to Pluto (and beyond!). The spacecraft launched in January 2006 and gets to Pluto in July 2015, after a Jupiter flyby in February 2007.

I wrote a slick web program (the New Horizons Geometry Visualizer, or just GV) which is being used by the science team to plan the encounter, and analyze a lot of the data from the Jupiter flyby.  It is essentially a planetarium package, showing you what the sky looks like from New Horizons as it cruises through the Solar System.  It can also be used for Cassini, Rosetta, Juno, and numerous other missions, as well as being very useful for planning observations from the Earth.

Planetary Rings

Voyager image

Cassini Mission to Saturn

When it was based at SWRI, I was associated with the Cassini ISS (Imaging Science Subsystem) instrument, which is Cassini's main visible-light camera. Among other things, I did the analysis of most of the observations of Jupiter's rings.

Origin & evolution of Saturn's G ring

A detailed light scattering model for realistic, icy, non-spherical particles, as applied to Voyager and HST data. We compared the present-day ring (location, optical thickness, particle size, radial profile) to end-results from a variety of origin scenarios, as predicted by the Roche-zone evolutionary model of R. Canup. Galileo image, Jovian main ring

Photometry & evolution of the Jovian ring system

We are also analyzing Galileo data of the Jovian rings, in particular for particle size distributions, to be used to compare to the output of long-term evolutionary models. We are currently working on generating accurate phase curves and spectra of the main ring, based on SSI and NIMS observations. Similar to our work with the G ring, we are able to constrain the size distributions far better by using both the spectra and phase curves than either one individually. Size-dependent particle dynamics will be calculated using the models of M. Horanyi, and formation histories constrained using the evolutionary models of R. Canup.

Publications

ADS list of publications

C.V. : PDF, HTML

Collaborators etc.

Alan Stern
Hal Levison
Leslie Young
David Nesvorny
Larry Esposito
John Bally
Robin Canup
Mihaly Horanyi
Bo Reipurth
Ted Snow
Shawn Brooks

Computer stuff

Linux on Dell Inspiron 8100

Links

Cassini
Southwest Research Institute, Boulder office
Colorado Rings Group
Department of Astrophysical & Planetary Sciences
CU Center for Astrobiology
Fiske Planetarium
 

Contact Info

How to contact me


Henry Throop, Southwest Research Institute / throop (at) boulder swri edu

Last modified 22-Oct-2008